As Halloween approaches, we often find ourselves revisiting the same iconic horror classics. While these films undeniably deserve their place in the spotlight, the world of horror offers a treasure trove of underrated gems that deliver spine-chilling thrills and unforgettable scares. For those looking to go beyond the mainstream, these overlooked horror films provide the perfect mix of psychological terror, supernatural elements, and innovative storytelling. Below, we delve into a selection of underrated horror films that are ideal for Halloween night.
Starry Eyes (2014)
One of the most unsettling psychological horrors to come out in recent years, Starry Eyes is a nightmarish journey through the dark side of Hollywood. The film centres around Sarah, an aspiring actress desperate to make it big in an industry that thrives on exploitation. When she auditions for a mysterious film role, she soon discovers the gruesome sacrifices required to achieve fame.
Starry Eyes masterfully blends body horror with a sharp critique of the entertainment industry, unravelling the disturbing lengths people are willing to go for success. Its chilling atmosphere and gradual descent into madness make it a must-watch for those who appreciate slow-burn horror. With deeply unsettling visuals and a commentary on the toxic nature of fame, it’s an excellent choice for a Halloween night in.
The Roost (2005)
Directed by Ti West, known for his mastery of slow-burn horror, The Roost pays homage to 1970s B-horror films. A group of friends find themselves stranded in a rural town on the night of Halloween, only to be terrorised by a colony of vampiric bats. The premise might sound simple, but The Roost offers an eerie atmosphere and a sense of dread that lingers throughout.
This film excels at building tension through its eerie score and minimalist setting. As the characters fight for survival, the relentless nature of the creatures gives the audience little time to breathe. If you’re a fan of vintage-style horror with a modern twist, The Roost is an excellent choice to add to your Halloween viewing list.
Livid (2011)
French horror has a well-deserved reputation for pushing the boundaries of the genre, and Livid is no exception. Directed by Alexandre Bustillo and Julien Maury, the film follows a trio of thieves who break into the mansion of a comatose woman, believing they’ll find treasure. However, they soon discover that the house holds far more sinister secrets than they could have anticipated.
Livid fuses dark fairy tale elements with graphic horror, creating a film that is visually stunning and deeply unnerving. The film shifts from a suspenseful heist narrative to a haunting supernatural horror, with otherworldly visuals that leave a lasting impression. Its blend of beauty and terror makes it a standout choice for anyone seeking something different this Halloween.
Pontypool (2008)
Pontypool offers a fresh and cerebral take on the zombie genre. Set in a small Canadian town, the film unfolds within a radio station where a group of employees begins receiving reports of violent riots occurring outside. As they piece together the events, they realise that the outbreak is being caused by a virus transmitted through language itself.
This highly original concept turns the zombie narrative on its head. Rather than relying on typical gore and jump scares, Pontypool is a tense psychological thriller that explores the power of words. Its unique premise and claustrophobic setting make it a gripping watch, perfect for those looking for an innovative horror experience this Halloween.
Cheap Thrills (2013)
If you enjoy your horror with a side of dark comedy, Cheap Thrills is a film you won’t want to miss. The story revolves around two old friends who are down on their luck when they encounter a wealthy couple offering them money to perform increasingly outrageous and dangerous dares. What starts as a seemingly harmless game quickly spirals into violence and moral degradation.
Cheap Thrills balances its macabre sense of humour with intense moments of horror, blurring the lines between the absurd and the horrifying. It’s a film that keeps viewers on edge, never quite knowing when the next horrific twist will come. The film’s exploration of human desperation and greed makes it as thought-provoking as it is terrifying, offering a unique blend of psychological horror and dark satire.
You Won’t Be Alone (2022)
Set in 19th-century Macedonia, You Won’t Be Alone is a haunting exploration of identity, transformation, and the human condition. The film follows a young girl who is transformed into a witch and embarks on a journey of self-discovery through the bodies of others.
While it’s a horror film at its core, You Won’t Be Alone blends folkloric elements with deeply philosophical themes, creating a meditative and atmospheric narrative. The film’s haunting visuals and eerie tone make it a standout within the genre, offering a thought-provoking experience for viewers looking for something more introspective this Halloween.
The Invitation (2015)
The Invitation is a masterclass in psychological tension. The film takes place at a dinner party hosted by a man’s ex-wife, where unsettling occurrences and strange behaviours lead him to suspect that something sinister is at play.
The film excels in its slow-burn approach, gradually building tension until it reaches an explosive climax. With its tightly woven script and strong performances, The Invitation keeps viewers on edge, never quite sure of what is real and what is paranoia. It’s a perfect choice for those who prefer a more character-driven horror experience, where the true terror comes from human behaviour.
Life After Beth (2014)
For those who enjoy horror-comedies, Life After Beth offers a quirky take on the zombie genre. The film stars Aubrey Plaza as Beth, a young woman who mysteriously returns from the dead after her boyfriend mourns her loss. What begins as a seemingly happy reunion quickly descends into chaos as Beth’s behaviour becomes increasingly erratic.
Balancing humour with moments of genuine horror, Life After Beth is a refreshing twist on the zombie genre. Its playful tone and sharp performances make it a fun and spooky option for Halloween night, offering plenty of laughs alongside its supernatural elements.
The House of the Devil (2009)
Another Ti West creation, The House of the Devil is a love letter to 1980s horror films. Set in the 80s, the film follows a young babysitter who takes on a job at a remote house, only to uncover a satanic ritual plot. The film is deliberately paced, building tension through atmosphere and suggestion rather than relying on overt scares.
What sets The House of the Devil apart is its dedication to recreating the aesthetic and feel of classic horror, complete with grainy visuals and an eerie synth soundtrack. Its slow-burn approach pays off with a chilling finale that stays with you long after the credits roll.
Lake Bodom (2016)
Inspired by a real-life unsolved murder case, Lake Bodom offers a chilling blend of slasher horror and psychological suspense. The film centres around a group of friends who venture to the infamous Lake Bodom to reconstruct the events of the unsolved murders that took place there decades ago. However, their plan quickly unravels as they find themselves stalked by an unknown force.
The film’s atmosphere is thick with tension, and its sharp twists and turns keep viewers guessing until the very end. Lake Bodom is a perfect choice for fans of slasher films looking for a new take on the genre, offering a blend of true crime inspiration and traditional horror elements.
These underrated horror films provide a wealth of chilling experiences for Halloween night. From psychological thrillers to supernatural tales and dark comedies, these films push the boundaries of the horror genre, offering something unique and terrifying. Whether you’re in the mood for slow-burn suspense, gruesome visuals, or innovative storytelling, these hidden gems are sure to deliver a haunting experience.